Teks -- Acts 5:29 (NET)

5:29 But Peter and the apostles replied, “We must obey God rather than people.

Tafsiran/Catatan -- Catatan Kata/Frasa (per frasa)

Robertson: Act 5:29 - We must

We must ( dei ).

Moral necessity left them no choice. They stood precisely where Peter and John were when before the Sanhedrin before (Act 4:20).

Robertson: Act 5:29 - Obey

Obey ( peitharchein ).

Old verb from peithomai and archē , to obey a ruler. Only by Luke and Paul in the N.T.

Vincent: Act 5:29 - We ought

We ought ( δεῖ )

Stronger, we must.

Vincent: Act 5:29 - To obey

To obey ( πειθαρχεῖν )

Not often used in the New Testament to express obedience, the most common word being ὑπακούω . Sometimes πείθω is used. But this word, in itself, is the only one of the several in use which expresses the conception of obedience exclusively. Ὑπακούνειν is to obey as the result of listening to another: πείθεσθαι is to obey as the result of persuasion . This is the special term for the obedience which one owes to authority (ἀρχή ): It occurs four times in the New Testament: Act 5:29, Act 5:32; Act 27:21; Tit 3:1; and in every case, of obedience to established authority, either of God or of magistrates. In Act 27:21, where it is used of the ship's officers hearkening to Paul's admonition not to loose from Crete, Paul speaks of his admonition as divinely inspired; compare Act 27:10. In Act 4:19, Peter and John say hearken (ἀκούειν ) . That is a mere listening to or considering the proposition made to them. This is a deliberate course of action.

Wesley: Act 5:29 - Then Peter

In the name of all the apostles, said - He does not now give them the titles of honour, which he did before, Act 4:8; but enters directly upon the subject, and justifies what he had done. This is, as it were, a continuation of that discourse, but with an increase of severity.

JFB: Act 5:29-30 - Then Peter, &c.

(See on Act 2:22, and Act 3:13, &c.).

Clarke: Act 5:29 - We ought to obey God rather than men

We ought to obey God rather than men - The same answer they gave before, Act 4:19, founded on the same reason, which still stood good. We have received our commission from God; we dare not lay it down at the desire or command of men. See the note on Act 4:19.

Calvin: Act 5:29 - NO PHRASE

29. This is the sum of their answer, It is lawful for them, nay, they ought to prefer God before men. God commandeth us to bear witness of Christ; therefore it is in vain for you to command us to keep silence. But I have declared before in the third chapter, when this sentence taketh place, that we ought rather to obey God than men. God doth set men over us in such sort with power, that he keepeth still his own authority safe and sound. Therefore, we must obey rulers so far, that the commandment of God be not broken. Whereas power and authority is lawfully used, then it is out of season to make comparison between God and man. If a faithful pastor do command or forbid out of the Word of God, it shall be in vain for men which are stubborn to object that we ought to obey God; for God will be heard by man. Yea, man is nothing else but an instrument of God. If a magistrate do his duty as he ought, a man shall in vain say that he is contrary to God, seeing that he dissenteth in nothing; yea, rather the contrary rule is then in force. We must obey God’s ministers and officers if we will obey him. ²⁶⁹ But so soon as rulers do lead us away from the obedience of God, because they strive against God with sacrilegious boldness, their pride must be abated, that God may be above all in authority. Then all smokes of honor vanish away. For God doth not vouchsafe to bestow honorable titles upon men, to the end they may darken his glory. Therefore, if a father, being not content with his own estate, do essay to take from God the chief honor of a father, he is nothing else but a man. If a king, or ruler, or magistrate, do become so lofty that he diminisheth the honor and authority of God, he is but a man. We must thus think also of pastors. For he which goeth beyond his bounds in his office, (because he setteth himself against God:) must be despoiled of his honor, lest, under a color or visor, he deceive. The office of a pastor is very excellent, the authority of the Church is great, yet so that no part of God’s power and Christ’s mastership be diminished. Whence we may easily gather that the pride of the Pope is ridiculous, who, when as he treadeth under foot the whole kingdom of Christ, and doth set himself openly against God, will yet, nevertheless, lie hid under the name of Christ. ²⁷⁰

Defender: Act 5:29 - ought to obey God

Christians are commanded to "be subject unto higher powers" (Rom 13:1) and to "submit yourselves to every ordinance of man for the Lord's sake" (1Pe 2:13), with this one exception. They had been commanded not to "teach in this name" (Act 5:28), but God had said: "Stand and speak" (Act 5:20). God's commands take priority, but they should be His commands, not our extensions of those commands."

TSK: Act 5:29 - We

We : Act 4:19; Gen 3:17; 1Sa 15:24; Mar 7:7-9; Rev 14:8-12

Tafsiran/Catatan -- Catatan Kata/Frasa (per Ayat)

Poole: Act 5:29

This they all agree in, and it is the common sense of all considering men; as Socrates in his apology told the Athenians, I embrace and love you, O Athenians, and yet I will obey God rather than you. This the apostles had formerly asserted, Act 4:19 .

Haydock: Act 5:29

Peter answered boldly, We ought to obey God, rather than men. And withal adds, that God had raised from death Jesus, the Prince and Saviour of mankind, by whose merits all might find repentance, and forgiveness of their sins; that they were witness of his resurrection, &c. (Witham)

Gill: Act 5:29 - Then Peter, and the other apostles, answered and said // we ought to obey God rather than men

Then Peter, and the other apostles, answered and said,.... Peter began, as the mouth of the apostles, being the eldest man, and very bold and zealous; and the rest followed, or joined, with him in what he said:

we ought to obey God rather than men; this is said in answer to the charge of disobedience to the orders and commands of the council: men, civil magistrates, and ecclesiastical rulers, are to be obeyed in things which are not repugnant to the will of God; but in things that are, God is to be obeyed, and not men. God had commanded by an angel, that the apostles should go to the temple, and there preach the doctrines of the Gospel; the sanhedrim had forbid them to speak and teach in the name of Christ; who were now to be obeyed? God, and not men: from whence it appears that the apostles were to be justified in disregarding the council, and neglecting its orders; and which is no ways contrary to that obedience and submission, that is to be yielded to those that are in authority, in things civil and lawful.